KAY Jewelers

1860 NE Pine Island Rd, Cape Coral, FL 33909, USA

Contact & Details

Location

What People Are Saying

Updated Review – December 31, 2025 Originally posted a 1- star review due to a very frustrating experience, but I’m happy to update this after Kay ultimately made things right
My hubby and I went in to look at wedding rings to get me an upgrade after 15 years
My mother and I came in to get my rings cleaned and ended up walking out with a few additional items

About KAY Jewelers

In Cape Coral, KAY Jewelers stands out not just for its jewelry but also for its customer service, often highlighted in reviews. Tammie McCormack has garnered praise for creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere when helping couples select their wedding rings. Her enthusiasm and knowledge made the experience memorable for many, leading to loyal customers who return for future jewelry needs. Whether you’re looking for an elegant upgrade or a special gift, Tammie’s expertise shines through.

However, experiences can vary, as shown in a notable case involving a wedding band repair that initially went awry. While the repair led to frustrations over communication and policy changes, KAY Jewelers ultimately rectified the situation, impressing the customer with a generous resolution. The leadership stepped in to ensure the right outcome, with special mentions of team members like Tammie and Christie facilitating a fair conclusion, restoring customer trust.

Additional services offered include ring cleanings and jewelry purchases, which have consistently drawn praise from customers who enjoy the personalized attention. With extended hours seven days a week, KAY Jewelers aims to cater to all customers, whether they’re seeking a simple repair or a stunning new piece. The blend of attentive service and commitment to resolving issues speaks to their dedication within the local community.

Is this your business?

Claim this listing to update your info, add photos, post deals, and connect with customers.

Claim This Listing